conduct as 'flat out a
and a 'ship about to
The American Spark
Blackwater's 'Sloppy Operation' In Iraq Exposed By House Panel
By Cliff Montgomery - Oct. 16th, 2007
In September 2007, the House Oversight Committee released a telling report entitled, Private Military
Contractors in Iraq, which examined Blackwater's Actions in Fallujah.
We quote from the executive summary below:
"On February 7, 2007, the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform held a hearing to initiate an
investigation into the performance and accountability of private military contractors in Iraq. The hearing
included the examination of one prominent case study: a pivotal event of the Iraq War in which four Blackwater
USA security contractors were ambushed and killed in Fallujah on March 31, 2004, while escorting a convoy.
"Since the hearing, the Committee has investigated what actually happened in Fallujah on March 31, 2004,
and whether Blackwater approached its security duties responsibly.
"As part of this investigation, the Committee staff has reviewed documents based on the accounts of eighteen
individuals with knowledge of the incident, including Blackwater’s Baghdad operations manager and project
director, seven other Blackwater personnel who were based in Iraq or Kuwait, the three truck drivers escorted
in the Blackwater convoy through Fallujah, and three personnel from a different government contractor who
spoke to the Blackwater team the night before and morning of its ambush, as well as employees of another
private security contractor and Blackwater’s contract partner.
"The Committee has also obtained, and the staff reviewed, unclassified investigative reports generated by the
counterintelligence unit of the Coalition Provisional Authority--the U.S. entity that was governing Iraq at the
time of the incident--and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service.
"These eyewitness accounts and investigative reports conflict with Blackwater’s assertion that they sent the
team out with sufficient preparation and equipment. They portray a company that ignored multiple warnings
about the dangers of traveling through Fallujah, cut essential personnel from the mission, and failed to supply
its team with armored vehicles, machine guns, sufficient threat intelligence, or even maps of the area.
"Blackwater’s own employees described its conduct as 'flat out a sloppy…operation' and a 'ship about to sink.'
[One] Blackwater employee stated: 'Why were they sent into the hottest zone in Iraq in unarmored,
underpowered vehicles to protect a truck? They had no way to protect their flanks because they only had four
"Even the internal review conducted by Blackwater at the direction of Erik Prince, the owner of Blackwater,
found that the team ambushed in Fallujah '[h]ad no time to perform proper mission planning' and '[w]as without
proper maps of the city.'
"The details of the events leading to the incident are disturbing, revealing an unprepared and disorderly
organization operating in a hostile environment. Mistake apparently compounded mistake. According to the
documents provided to the Committee:
- At the time of the Fallujah incident, Blackwater was taking over operations from a British security
company, Control Risks Group. The project manager for the British company states that Blackwater 'did
not use the opportunity to learn from the experience gained by CRG on this operation,…leading to
inadequate preparation for taking on this task.'
The company’s incident report states that Blackwater was informed that Control Risks Group
twice rejected the mission because of unacceptable security risks, reporting: 'Blackwater were informed
that we had turned this task down and the reasons why were given.'
- Prior to the Blackwater team’s departure, two of the six members of the team were cut from the mission,
depriving both security vehicles of a rear gunner. These personnel were removed from the mission to
perform administrative duties at the Blackwater operations center.
- Blackwater had a contract dispute with a Kuwaiti company, Regency Hotel & Hospitality, over the
acquisition of armored vehicles for the Blackwater team.
Blackwater officials instructed its employees to 'string these guys along and run this…thing into the
ground' because 'if we stalled long enough they (Regency) would have no choice but to buy us armored
cars, or they would default on the contract,' in which case the contractor who hired Regency 'might go
directly to Blackwater for security.'
According to a Blackwater employee, Blackwater’s contract 'paid for armor vehicles,' but 'management
in North Carolina made the decision to go with soft skin due to the cost.'
- One day before the Fallujah attack, Blackwater’s operations manager in Baghdad sent an urgent email
to Blackwater headquarters in North Carolina with the subject line 'Ground Truth.' The email stated: 'I
need new vehicles. I need new COMs, I need ammo, I need Glocks and M4s. […] I've requested hard cars
from the beginning. […] Ground truth is appalling.'
- Because they were without maps and the mission had not been sufficiently planned, the Blackwater
personnel arrived at the wrong military base the day before the attack, where they were forced to spend
the night. A witness at the military base assessed that 'the mission that they were on was hurriedly put
together and that they were not prepared.' "
Like what you're reading so far? Then why not order a full year (52 issues) of the The American Spark e-
newsletter for only $15? A major article covering an story not being told in the Corporate Press will be
delivered to your email every Monday morning for a full year, for less than 30 cents an issue. Order Now!